About this trial
A growing body of literature documents the benefits of parent-mediated interventions for autism starting early in life . However, the median age of diagnosis in the US continues to be 49 months. Even following formal diagnosis, services often do not begin for another 9 months on average. Such harmful delays in accessing autism-specific early interventions are potentially avoidable, as caregivers of children later diagnosed with autism identify concerns about their child's development by 13 months on average - including difficulties that can be successfully addressed through evidence-based intervention practices. Wait times to receive a formal diagnosis of autism are such a significant barrier that they have been referred to as a "crisis" in the field, with parents reporting an average wait time of 1.2 years in the US. The current proposal focuses on circumventing the roadblock of delayed access to diagnosis and intervention by empowering caregivers to address their children's needs before a diagnosis is established.
This will be accomplished through the implementation and evaluation of the "Online Parent Training in Early Behavioral Intervention (OPT-In-Early)", a self-directed online resource for caregivers of autistic children which will be made available during their enrollment in waitlists for a diagnostic evaluation. Key features of OPT-In-Early include: (a) a comprehensive scope (i.e., multiple developmental domains are addressed), (b) a focus on evidence-based Naturalistic Developmental Behavioral Intervention strategies, (c) a combination of required and optional modules, so that caregivers can focus on areas most relevant to their child's needs, and (d) access to online materials designed for self-directed implementation, as well as access to remote consultation with a clinician for advice, clarification and support (including on selection of appropriate modules).
Following an alternative approach to the current "parental concerns - then enrollment in waitlist - then clinical diagnosis - then intervention", the program is designed to counteract the harmful and frustrating inaction that characterizes the waitlist time with timely action designed to address areas of concern that caregivers have already identified and should be empowered to address. This has the potential to capitalize on the window of opportunity of early brain plasticity, thus maximizing outcomes, and to reduce the anxiety associated with the lack of services that characterizes the period of "passive waiting" for a formal diagnosis. To evaluate the utility of this innovative resource, the following specific aims will be addressed:
1. Comparing outcomes for 120 toddlers aged 16-48 months whose caregivers are on a waitlist to receive a formal autism diagnosis, randomly assigned to receive either OPT-In-Early or no intervention during a six-month period. The investigators predict that (a) children randomized to the OPT-In-Early condition will have superior gains as reflected in the Goal Attainment Scaling, changes in adaptive behavior and social communication standardized measures, and (b) their families will experience superior improvements in their well-being. 2. Examining implementation outcomes of feasibility and acceptability of the intervention. The investigators predict high acceptability and feasibility for the OPT-In-Early content and format, as indicated by end-users' responses to standardized measures reflecting 80%+ agreement on the feasibility and acceptability of the program. 3. As an exploratory aim, investigators will examine theoretically- and empirically- motivated factors associated with intervention uptake and child outcomes, including demographic profiles and child clinical presentation.
Examining whether accessing and using OPT-In-Early during waitlist time is a viable alternative to the current "first diagnosis then intervention" format (for all children, or for children with specific profiles and needs) is a critical step toward promoting a more efficient intervention delivery model, bridging the gap between onset of parental concerns and availability of intervention practices designed to target such concerns.
Eligibility criteria
This trial does not accept healthy volunteersQualifiers
age between 16-48 months,
parental consent
being on a waitlist to receive a formal diagnostic evaluation at the time of parent consent due to autism concerns
parents speak English
Disqualifiers
having already received a formal diagnosis of autism
enrollment in early intervention programs delivering more than 5 h per week of evidence-based autism-specific interventions at the time of consent
child has a gestational age less than 36 weeks associated with a birth weight less than 2500 g
the child is not yet walking, or has severe hearing and/or vision impairment that is uncorrected with aids, or known neurological disorder or genetic syndrome (e.g., Down syndrome).
Trial design
Parallel
Treatments tested in this trial
Online Parent Training in Early Behavioral Intervention (OPT-In-Early)
Behavioralthe "Online Parent Training in Early Behavioral Intervention" (OPT-In-Early; Dai et al., 2018, 2021,2022) is a self-directed online resource for caregivers of children with autism or high likelihood of autism. The OPT-In-Early program includes 14 modules (6 mandatory, 8 optional) comprising text and video demonstrations to teach caregivers effective methods for improving their children's language, social, and adaptive skills (e.g., using utensils, toilet training), and reducing their children's disruptive behavior. Parents are taught how to facilitate joint attention, imitation, pretend play, language, sharing, emotional engagement, social play, and self-help skills such as feeding and dressing in their child using behavioral principles (e.g. prompting, shaping and fading) during play and naturalistic daily routines. The optional modules cover such topics as picky eating and toilet training.
Treatment groups
Trial outcomes
Primary outcomes
Goal Attainment Scaling
The Goal Attainment Scaling (GAS) is a proximal measure of intervention response, i.e., a measure that captures changes in the specific goals selected for each participant. The GAS is designed to assess an individual's progress on a goal in relation to their baseline performance. The GAS includes standardized procedures to generate a common metric of intervention change across participants who have different intervention goals. For each participant, goals are developed based on areas in which the child is experiencing difficulties (e.g., picky eating, toilet training, self-injurious behavior) that caregivers want to address by teaching specific skills. Videos provided by the caregivers at pre- and post- intervention are rated according to the GAS standard procedures on a 5-point scale, whereby positive changes in score from baseline indicating increasingly positive benchmarks of improvement from the baseline to post-intervention.
Secondary outcomes
Vineland Scales of Adaptive Behavior-3
The Vineland Scales of Adaptive Behavior-3 (VABS-3), a standardized parent interview measuring adaptive functioning, will be administered to all participants at pre- and post-treatment to evaluate change occurring in adaptive behavior across groups. Previous research has documented that this measure has robust psychometric properties, is sensitive to change in response to early intervention, and captures dimensions that are highly valued by stakeholders. Higher scores in the VABS indicate more advanced adaptive skills.
Parenting Stress Index-4, Short-Form
The Parenting Stress Index-4, Short-Form (PSI), a standardized measure of parental wellbeing with robust psychometric properties, which has been used in previous research with a similar population. Higher scores in the PSI indicate more parenting stress.
Autism Impact Measure (AIM)
The Autism Impact Measure (AIM) is a caregiver-report questionnaire that focuses on the frequency and impact of autism-associated challenges in social interaction, communication, peer interaction as well as repetitive and unusual behaviors. It will be administered at baseline and post-intervention to assess changes in social and communication functioning across groups. The AIM has been shown to have robust psychometric properties. Higher scores in the AIM indicate higher frequency and impact of autism-associated challenges.
Other outcomes
Acceptability of Intervention Measure
The Acceptability of Intervention Measure is a standardized measure assessing the extent to which end-users believe the intervention was acceptable. Participants are asked to rate the acceptability of the program overall as well as each specific module they utilized. Higher scores indicate higher acceptability.
Feasibility of Intervention Measure
The Feasibility of Intervention Measure is a standardized questionnaire assessing the extent to which end-users believe the intervention can be successfully carried out. To gain insight on feasibility issues related to specific modules, participants will be asked to rate the program overall as well as each specific module they utilized. Higher scores indicate higher feasibility.
Sponsors and contacts
Click on the lead sponsor to view all of their trials.
Drexel University
Lead sponsor
Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (NICHD)
Collaborator