The Effectiveness of a Diet With Beef as Key Protein Component Versus a Plant-Based Diet to Support Integrated Muscle Protein Synthesis Rates in Healthy Older Individuals

Trial statusRecruiting
Trial phaseNot applicable
Trial typeInterventional
Biological sexAll
Age65-85
SponsorMaastricht University Medical Center

About this trial

Muscles are composed out of proteins. These proteins in turn are composed out of smaller building blocks, called amino acids. By consuming a sufficient amount of dietary protein, a sufficient amount of amino acids become available to build new muscle proteins. The body's ability to build these new muscle proteins is of great importance to maintain muscle strength and function.

Previous research suggests that a meal containing proteins from meat results in a better stimulation of the body's ability to build muscle proteins, when compared to a meal containing only plant-based proteins. However, these previous studies have only been performed following the ingestion of a single meal. As a result it is currently unknown how the muscles respond to a more prolonged ingestion of a diet containing animal/meat products, in comparison to a plant-based diet. Therefore, this study aims to investigate how fast new muscle proteins are being build when consuming a diet containing animal/meat products, in comparison to a plant-based (vegan) diet.

Eligibility criteria

This trial accepts healthy volunteers

Qualifiers

Male or female sex

Aged between 65 and 85 y inclusive

BMI between 18.5 and 30 kg/m2 inclusive

Disqualifiers

Not willing to consume meat/animal-based products during the study period

Any food allergies (e.g. milk, gluten, etc.)

Participating currently or in the 3 months prior to the study in a structured progressive exercise program.

Smoking

Trial design

Design model

Crossover

Treatments tested in this trial

  • Meat diet

    Other intervention

    Participants will be subjected to a 10-day diet containing meat and animal products. During the interventional period participants will perform unilateral lower limb resistance exercise.

  • Plant diet

    Other intervention

    Participants will be subjected to a 10-day diet containing plant products. During the interventional period participants will perform unilateral lower limb resistance exercise.

Treatment groups

32 Participants
are divided into 2 treatment groups
Group A: MEAT-PLANTExperimental treatment 2 interventions
Group B: PLANT-MEATExperimental treatment 2 interventions

Trial outcomes

Primary outcomes

1

Integrated muscle protein synthesis rate in rested leg

The main study endpoint will be the difference in muscle protein synthesis rates in the non-exercised leg, between the plant-based diet and the meat diet, expressed as FSR (%/day).

Time frame
The 2 intervention periods over which FSR is determined will each last 10 days

Secondary outcomes

1

Integrated muscle protein synthesis rate in exercised leg

The difference in muscle protein synthesis rates in the exercised leg, between the plant-based diet and the meat diet, expressed as FSR (%/day).

Time frame
The 2 intervention periods over which FSR is determined will each last 10 days
2

Blood glucose

The difference in plasma glucose concentrations will be determined following the MEAT vs PLANT diet

Time frame
The 2 intervention periods after which the outcomes are determined will each last 10 days
3

Blood insulin

The difference in plasma, insulin, will be determined following the MEAT vs PLANT diet

Time frame
The 2 intervention periods after which the outcomes are determined will each last 10 days
4

Blood lipid profile

The difference in blood lipid profile will be determined following the MEAT vs PLANT diet

Time frame
The 2 intervention periods after which the outcomes are determined will each last 10 days

Other outcomes

1

Participant characteristics

Participants characteristics at baseline will be reported as descriptives. This includes: Age, sex, body mass, height, BMI, Body composition as assed by DEXA scan, habitual dietary intake, habitual physical activity.

Time frame
At baseline, before start interventional period
2

Muscle histology characteristics

Muscle histology characteristics at baseline will be reported as descriptive.

Time frame
At baseline, before start interventional period
3

Muscle signaling proteins

The difference in muscle signaling protein between the plant-based diet and the meat diet.

Time frame
The 2 intervention periods over which muscle signaling proteins are determined will each last 10 days
4

Dietary intake

The dietary intake during the 2 interventional periods will be compared. Measured by dietary intake records

Time frame
The 2 intervention periods that will be compared will each last 10 days

Sponsors and contacts

Click on the lead sponsor to view all of their trials.

Maastricht University Medical Center

Lead sponsor

National Cattlemen's Beef Association, a contractor to the Beef Checkoff

Collaborator