About this trial
This project will (a) examine the relationship between knowledge retrieval and inferencing; (b) determine the effectiveness of an intervention that improves knowledge retrieval and inferencing among struggling readers; and (c) expand research opportunities for undergraduates. The research design uses 316 struggling readers in grades 4-6 of diverse backgrounds. The effects of knowledge retrieval (accuracy and speed) on inferencing will be modeled without dichotomizing the distribution. Linear mixed effect models will be fit to determine whether reader characteristics make unique contributions to inferencing across the posttest and follow-up data collection time points. First, several structural models will be considered as students may be nested in teachers, schools, and tutors. Unconditional models will estimate the intraclass correlation for each level of the study design. If significant interclass correlations emerge, multilevel models will be fit to evaluate the effectiveness of the intervention while controlling for covariates such as pre-test performance on inference-related measures and child-attributes such as English learner status. The primary analysis plan assumes an intent-to-treat model in which the efficacy of two intact conditions will be tested. Effect sizes will be estimated to report the magnitude of difference between the two conditions. Expected outcomes include (a) the identification of a method that effectively facilitates knowledge retrieval and the application of relevant knowledge to form inferences among elementary struggling readers from diverse backgrounds; (b) the validation of an intervention that teaches struggling readers how to activate, retrieve, and interweave relevant knowledge with information in the text and accurately form inferences while reading that can be broadly implemented in general education classrooms; and (c) expansion of undergraduate research opportunities, particularly among students from diverse backgrounds who have been historically underserved.
Eligibility criteria
This trial does not accept healthy volunteersQualifiers
performance below a a standard score of 93 on the Test of Silent Reading Efficiency
Disqualifiers
clinical diagnosis of a significant cognitive impairment
clinical diagnosis of a significant behavioral disability
Trial design
Parallel
Treatments tested in this trial
Role of Knowledge Retrieval
BehavioralStudents will learn a new knowledge base to perfect mastery. Following the attainment of mastery students will read passages on the topic and answer questions that prompt the literal recall of key facts and the formation of inferences.
Inference Intervention
BehavioralThe intervention will pre-teach students a set of 20 essential facts about Egypt. Students will interact with expository and narrative texts. Students will practice using a text clue strategy to activate and integrate prior knowledge, will make in-text connections, connections across the 3 intervention texts, and connections between text and knowledge, and will make inferences about character motives and author intent. The tutor will ask students to justify connections and evaluate how these connections enhance understanding. Students will answer inference questions that require using text and background knowledge. A simple graphic organizer will support and scaffold inferencing. Throughout the intervention, students will practice retrieving the 20 essential facts about Egypt from memory using flash cards, completed in pairs with students providing each other feedback.
Treatment groups
Trial outcomes
Primary outcomes
Gates-MacGinite Reading Test-4th Edition; Change is being assessed
a standardized, group-administered, multiple-choice assessment of reading comprehension.
Gates-MacGinite Reading Test-4th Edition; change is being assessed
a standardized, group-administered, multiple-choice assessment of reading comprehension
Test of Language Competence-Expanded; Change is being assessed
Inference Task asks students to read three sentences and form an inference
Test of Language Competence-Expanded; change is being assessed
Inference Task asks students to read three sentences and form an inference
Secondary outcomes
Knowledge Retrieval; change is being assessed
It teaches new knowledge then measures the accuracy and efficiency by which the individual can retrieve that knowledge. After learning the knowledge base, students read passages and form inferences with the accuracy and efficiency of inferencing measured.
Knowledge Retrieval; change is being assessed
It teaches new knowledge then measures the accuracy and efficiency by which the individual can retrieve that knowledge. After learning the knowledge base, students read passages and form inferences with the accuracy and efficiency of inferencing measured.
Knowledge Retrieval; change is being assessed
It teaches new knowledge then measures the accuracy and efficiency by which the individual can retrieve that knowledge. After learning the knowledge base, students read passages and form inferences with the accuracy and efficiency of inferencing measured.
Knowledge Retrieval; change is being assessed
It teaches new knowledge then measures the accuracy and efficiency by which the individual can retrieve that knowledge. After learning the knowledge base, students read passages and form inferences with the accuracy and efficiency of inferencing measured.
Other outcomes
Test of Silent Reading Efficiency and Comprehension
measure of silent reading fluency and understanding of text
Sponsors and contacts
Click on the lead sponsor to view all of their trials.