Hydroxyapatite Toothpastes and Enamel Remineralization:

Trial statusRecruiting
Trial phaseNot applicable
Trial typeInterventional
Biological sexAll
Age6-18
SponsorUniversity of Pavia

About this trial

This randomized controlled clinical trial aims to evaluate the efficacy of two commercially available toothpastes containing hydroxyapatite in the remineralization of early enamel lesions. The study compares Biorepair® Total Protection Plus, which contains biomimetic microRepair particles, with Bioniq® Repair, a conventional hydroxyapatite-based toothpaste.

Forty participants will be randomly assigned to either the trial group (Biorepair®) or the control group (Bioniq®), and both groups will receive quarterly professional dental cleanings and use the assigned toothpaste twice daily for 6 months.

The primary outcome is the change in enamel demineralization, assessed by DIAGNOdent Pen scores, in permanent molar fissures and upper central incisors. Secondary outcomes include enamel integrity assessed by DIAGNOcam imaging and ICDAS scores, as well as changes in dental sensitivity (Schiff Air Index), erosive wear (BEWE Index), plaque accumulation (Plaque Index), gingival inflammation (Bleeding Index), and extrinsic stains (Modified Lobene Stain Index). Patient satisfaction will also be evaluated at the end of the study using a self-administered questionnaire.

This study will help determine whether biomimetic hydroxyapatite offers superior benefits in maintaining enamel health compared to conventional formulations, supporting evidence-based preventive strategies in dental care.

Eligibility criteria

This trial does not accept healthy volunteers

Qualifiers

Subjects aged between 6 and 18 years

Ability to understand and follow instructions in Italian or English

Signed written informed consent provided by the parent/legal guardian and assent from the minor

Good cooperation and adherence to clinical instructions

Disqualifiers

DIAGNOdent Pen values greater than 25

Ongoing systemic antibiotic therapy

Presence of sealants or composite restorations on first permanent molars or upper central incisors

Severe enamel alterations such as molar-incisor hypomineralization (MIH), fluorosis, or extensive white/brown spot lesions

Trial design

Design model

Parallel

Treatments tested in this trial

  • Biorepair® Total Protection Plus Toothpaste

    Drug

    Participants will use Biorepair® Total Protection Plus toothpaste twice daily for 6 months. The toothpaste contains biomimetic microRepair® particles based on zinc-substituted hydroxyapatite, intended to promote enamel remineralization, reduce sensitivity, and protect against erosion and plaque accumulation. Professional dental cleanings will also be performed every 3 months.

  • Bioniq® Toothpaste

    Drug

    Participants will use Bioniq® Repair toothpaste twice daily for 6 months. The toothpaste contains 20% conventional hydroxyapatite and is designed to restore enamel, reduce dentin hypersensitivity, and protect against erosion. Professional dental cleanings will also be performed every 3 months.

Treatment groups

40 Participants
are divided into 2 treatment groups
Group A: Biorepair GroupExperimental treatment 1 intervention
Group B: Bioniq GroupActive comparator 1 intervention

Trial outcomes

Primary outcomes

1

Change in DIAGNOdent Pen values in enamel fissures and upper central incisors

o assess the remineralizing efficacy of biomimetic hydroxyapatite (Biorepair® Total Protection Plus) compared to conventional hydroxyapatite (Bioniq® Repair) by evaluating the reduction in DIAGNOdent Pen fluorescence values recorded in the occlusal fissures of permanent molars and on the surfaces of upper central incisors. Measurements will be taken at four timepoints (T0, T1, T2, T3) over a 6-month period. The DIAGNOdent Pen provides a numerical score (0-99) based on laser fluorescence, where higher values indicate increased enamel demineralization. Lower values after treatment reflect improved enamel health and remineralization.

Time frame
Baseline to 6 months (T0-T3)

Secondary outcomes

1

Change in ICDAS Scores via DIAGNOcam Imaging

To assess enamel demineralization using the International Caries Detection and Assessment System (ICDAS) recorded through DIAGNOcam transillumination images. The PI will assign ICDAS scores to the occlusal surfaces of permanent molars and labial surfaces of upper central incisors at each timepoint. The ICDAS scoring system ranges from 0 to 6, where a score of 0 indicates sound tooth structure, scores of 1 and 2 represent initial changes in enamel, and scores from 3 to 6 reflect progressive levels of localized enamel breakdown and cavitation. A decrease in score over time is interpreted as a sign of remineralization or lesion arrest.

Time frame
Baseline to 6 months (T0-T3)
2

Change in Dentin Hypersensitivity Using Schiff Air Index

To evaluate dentin hypersensitivity in response to an air stimulus applied to exposed cervical surfaces using the Schiff Air Index. The clinician will assign a score from 0 to 3, where a score of 0 indicates no reaction, 1 indicates a reaction without the patient requesting discontinuation, 2 indicates a reaction and a request to stop, and 3 indicates a strong reaction and immediate request to discontinue. The score reflects the participant's response to air-blast stimulation and will be recorded at each timepoint. A decrease in score suggests reduced hypersensitivity.

Time frame
Baseline to 6 months (T0-T3)
3

Change in Enamel Erosion Using BEWE Index

To monitor changes in enamel erosion using the Basic Erosive Wear Examination (BEWE) index. The examiner will assess each sextant and assign a score from 0 to 3. A score of 0 indicates no erosive tooth wear, a score of 1 indicates initial surface loss, a score of 2 represents distinct defects with hard tissue loss involving less than 50% of the surface area, and a score of 3 indicates hard tissue loss affecting more than 50% of the surface. The highest score per sextant is recorded, and a cumulative BEWE score is calculated for each participant at every timepoint. A reduction in the BEWE score suggests improved enamel preservation.

Time frame
Baseline to 6 months (T0-T3)
4

Change in Plaque Accumulation Using Plaque Index

To evaluate changes in plaque accumulation between groups using the Plaque Index (Silness and Löe, 1964), which measures plaque thickness along the gingival margin. The scoring system ranges from 0 to 3. A score of 0 indicates no plaque. A score of 1 corresponds to a thin film of plaque adhering to the free gingival margin and adjacent area of the tooth, which is only detectable by running a probe across the tooth surface. A score of 2 represents moderate accumulation of soft deposits visible to the naked eye, either on the tooth surface or within the gingival margin. A score of 3 indicates heavy accumulation of soft debris in the gingival pocket or on the tooth and gingival margin. The PI assigns a score for each examined surface, and the average value per participant is calculated at each timepoint (T0-T3).

Time frame
Baseline to 6 months (T0-T3)

Other outcomes

Sponsors and contacts

Click on the lead sponsor to view all of their trials.